Seventh Circuit: “Unfortunate Circumstances” Not Enough to Warrant Pension Payments to Deceased Worker’s Daughter

Jun 19, 2018 | Blog |

Andrew B. Bryant - Chicago insurance attorney

By: Andrew B. Bryant

Mother Died Three Days Before Pension Payments Would Have Vested With Daughter

In a truly unfortunate set of circumstances, a woman who worked for 37 years at a Wisconsin children’s hospital passed away three days after her retirement date, with her pension payments set to begin another three days after he date of death.   The woman’s daughter, the named beneficiary under the pension plan (“the Plan”), was denied payments under the Plan because the date of death preceded the beginning of pension payments.  

In upholding the denial of benefits, the Seventh Circuit noted that in order to avoid certain potential tax implications under 26 U.S.C. § 401(a)(9), the Plan made clear that only spouses were entitled to collect benefits when the participant dies before Plan payments begin.    As such, even though the mother named her daughter as a beneficiary in Plan documents, the daughter was not eligible to receive any benefits because the Plan participant died before the onset of pension payments (albeit only three days).    In its ruling, the Seventh Circuit found that the Plan Administrator’s decision was reasonable given the Plan’s intent to avoid named tax consequences, and that the decision was not arbitrary and capricious.    In addressing areas lacking clarity in the Plan documents, the Seventh Circuit deferred to the Plan administrator, noting that the courts should give deference to a Plan administrator’s interpretation when plan language is ambiguous.   

See, Jones v. Children’s Hospital, Case No. 17-3524 (7th Cir. 2018).

Bryant Legal Group - Chicago Healthcare and Disability Attorneys


"Mr Bryant, his partner Jennifer Danish and associate Steve Jackson were efficient, diligent and persistent towards finding a just resolution and favorable outcome for myself and my entire company."

"I used Jennifer Danish for a disability claim. Frustrated that I couldn’t get results myself I found her. She unearthed some issues my doctor did Not notify me of that affect the quality of my life. My end result was positive!"

"Mr. Jackson did an outstanding job in relation to my case. He insured I was. Both prepared as well as informed regarding the hearing. I would highly recommend his skills and personal dedication to the client."

"Though difficult for the obvious reasons, your involvement has made this process infinitely more tolerable. Please know of my sincere appreciation for your efforts. With Very Best Regards,"

Contact Us For A Free Consultation

Contact Us Now

Is this for a disability claim?

Bryant Legal Group PC Bryant Legal Group PC


55 E Monroe St,
Ste 1460

Chicago, IL 60603

Main Line: 312-561-3010
Fax: 312-254-3140

Free Consultation